Who’s the New Voice of Jimmy Pesto on Bob’s Burgers?

The Gist:

• The voice actor for Jimmy Pesto in Bob’s Burgers was replaced for this season onward.
• The previous actor who portrayed the rival character was tied to severe controversy.
• We break down who the new voice actor is and where you might have heard him before.

If we had a nickel for every time a prominent voice actor from a popular adult animated series was removed from their role on the show due to real-world controversy, there would be more nickels than you think. In 2023, Rick and Morty creator and voice star Justin Roiland was fired from his many roles on the show after he was implicated in allegations of domestic battery. Though criminal charges were levied against him, he was still replaced as the voice of both title characters.

In the same year, Bob’s Burgers underwent similar changes with one of its most prominent characters. With the show having returned for its 14th season on Oct. 1, fans will have undoubtedly noticed a change in one of its recurring characters, Jimmy Pesto. The character’s voice actor was fully replaced as of Season 14. Here’s who’s voicing Jimmy Pesto now and what happened with his old voice actor.

The long-running animated sitcom follows the eccentric Belcher family who operate and live out of their own burger joint called Bob’s Burgers. Father and level-headed burger chef Bob (H. Jon Benjamin); his wife Linda (John Roberts); and their children Tina (Dan Mintz), Gene (Eugene Mirman) and Louise (Kristen Schaal) try to keep the family business afloat all while getting into some wacky situations.

Naturally, Bob has plenty of competition in the food industry, none more vindictive than Jimmy Pesto.

Jimmy Pesto Sr. (Jay Johnston) operates his own Italian restaurant called Jimmy Pesto’s Pizzeria right across from Bob’s Burgers and typically brings in more customers. Being fully aware of his own success, Jimmy typically uses every opportunity to lord his popularity over Bob, much to the burger chef’s chagrin.

As Bob’s rival, Jimmy is a very prominent character in the series. However, his longtime voice actor underwent a big change.

As of Season 14, which premiered in 2023, Jay Johnston was replaced by voice actor Eric Bauza as the voice of Jimmy Pesto. The recast comes after controversy emerged surrounding Jay’s political stance.