Who Is Starfish on The Masked Singer?

It’s a whole new lineup of singers, themes, and costumes in Season 11 of The Masked Singer. The latest installment of the reality singing competition features all sorts of changes and surprises, including popular singer Rita Ora subbing in for Nicole Scherzinger while the latter is away. Yet despite this temporary shake-up to the formula, there’s still no shortage of new costumes and shocking performances as we try to guess which celebrities are under which masks.

One of those masks includes Starfish, which has to be one of the most outlandish costumes on the show so far, even for The Masked Singer. This blue starfish character has enormous eyes and bright scuba gear with a glittery mic on the snorkel. Here’s what we know about Starfish’s identity on The Masked Singer.

Episode 1 Clues:

• Cup of office supplies
• “When I was just starting out, I was serving steaks to the stars.”
• Rubbed elbows with Steve Martin and Whitney Houston
• Four leaf clover
• Doll
• A clock showing 9 o’clock and the words “50 Billion.” Starfish said, “I’ve been streamed over 50 billion minutes — and that was just in one year!”

Episode 6 Clues:

• Jukebox
• Fishbowl with a “Teacher’s Lounge” label
• “LIVE” sign
• Merch table
• Transformers Night Clue: “A true teammate, Starfish has earned awards as part of a talented group.”

Spoiler alert! While we don’t know for sure who is behind the [MASK NAME] mask, the correct identity may be spoiled in the guesses below.

Episode 1 Guesses:

• Rita — Catherine O’Hara
• Robin — Cheri Oteri
• Jenny — Molly Shannon

Episode 6 Guesses:

• Jenny: Amy Poehler
• Robin: Tina Fey
• Rita: Maya Rudolph

Starfish hasn’t been revealed on the show quite yet! We’ll be sure to update as soon as they are, though!

Season 11 of The Masked Singer kicks off every Wednesday at 8 p.m. EST on Fox.