When Carlton joined RHOBH in Season 4, she immediately stood out from the 90210 ladies. She and Kyle Richards were at odds almost instantly, as Kyle admitted to being afraid of Carlton because she identifies as a witch. Carlton explained she practiced Wicca and learned the craft from her grandmother.
Kyle accused Carlton of putting a “spell” on her computer. While she denied using any magic, Carlton got fired from RHOBH after one season, which she took in stride.