As Britt was exiting the Bachelor mansion following the news that the contestants had not picked her to stay on as the lead of Season 11, Brady Toops followed her. He explained that he had gone on the show for her, and that he wanted to pursue a relationship off the show. The two dated while Kaitlyn’s season was airing on ABC. Viewers were provided weekly updates about their relationship on the show.

In July of 2015, Britt confirmed that she had split from the Christian singer.

“Yes, it is true – Brady Toops and I are no longer together. We had a wonderful, sweet, and life-giving relationship that I appreciated, learned from, and thoroughly enjoyed. Brady is one of the most genuine, godly, encouraging, generous, kind, intelligent, and all-around amazing men on the planet. We broke up about two months ago, but still remain very close friends…” she wrote per Us Weekly in the now-deleted Instagram photo. 

Within a year of her breakup with Brady, Britt began dating salon owner and singer Jeremy Byrne. The two originally met in July of 2011 when they were set up by a mutual friend, but they parted ways before Britt went on The Bachelor. Jeremy later got engaged to someone else, but they reconnected after Britt broke up with Brady. Interestingly, Brady and Jeremy were friends before Brady went on The Bachelorette. 

Britt and Jeremy announced their engagement in May of 2017, and Britt later revealed on Instagram that he proposed while the two were sitting on their couch at home. 

While planning her wedding, Britt appeared on an episode of TLC’s Say Yes to the Dress Atlanta, which aired in 2018. 

Jeremy and Britt got married in September of 2017 at a ranch in Vista, California.