Previously, Alexis had dated her DWTS partner Alan Bersten, but the pair split back in December 2018. At the time, the pair had been on good terms, and claimed it was their conflicting schedules that made it hard for them to stay together, insinuating that maybe they would get together again later. But Alexis’ relationship to Noah makes that impossible.

It’s OK, we think Noah and Alexis are cuter together, anyway.