38 Unpersonalized Gifts That Feel Very Personal

Each box includes Tie-Dye (vanilla), Cookie & Cream, Peanut Butter & Jelly, Cookie Dough, Triple Chocolate Fudge, Chocolate Chip Pancake, Red Velvet, Mint Cookie, Chocolate Caramel Crumble, Chocolate Candy Crunch, Chocolate & Cookie Butter, and Toasted Cinnamon.

I bolded the ones that are my favorite because I live down the street from a Baked By Melissa and I am legiiiiiit in there at least once a week to treat myself to a six-pack. These are some of my favorite desserts of all time, and I am a major dessert snob. I’ve also had them shipped as gifts before, and they taste every bit as fresh-tasting shipped as they are in person out of the bakery! (To be clear, yes, I had them shipped as gifts, but then ate some myself. I am…maybe bad at gifts.)

Promising review: “Incredible product. Arrived on time and in great condition! My friends who I gave them to we’re thrilled and ate all of them within three days!! They said the were delicious and they kept snacking on them. Then they called me, reminded me when their birthdays were and said they’d appreciate more…” —Craigers

Shipping: Choose your shipping date in advance, or standard one-to-two-day shipping with expedited and priority shipping available at additional cost (plus pick-up and delivery options in Manhattan). 

Get it from Baked By Melissa for $30+ (also available in 50-packs and 100-packs), and get vegan, gluten-free, and party-safe (no nut flavors) cupcake gift sets for $30+–$42+ as well.