25 Products Reviewers In Their 40s Are Pretty Fond Of

The tool comes with two ends, one a small eyebrow brush and the other a specially edged eyebrow pencil.

Promising review: “I’ve significantly reduced how much/what types of makeup I’ve been using (only using under-eye concealer, eye brightener, and mascara). Instead, I focus on a great skincare routine, which has dramatically improved my skin (I’m 42, and this is HUGE for me), and I only use makeup on my eyes, and a ChapStick or tinted lip moisturizer. 

Prior to buying this, I didn’t use anything on my brows, because, besides a couple barely noticeable spots where they were thinner, they’re pretty okay. I bought this, just to try, because the price was great. This pencil is very forgiving. If you put on too much you can easily blend it in with the spool on the other end. 

I got the soft brown, which was a perfect match. You can also wipe any off with your finger or a cotton swab if you get it on the skin above or below your brow. I do like the look of my eyes when I use the pencil to define my brows. I think my eyes look more striking and awake. I’ll continue to use this product, and I would buy it again. The first day I got this, I tried it at night, forgot I had it on, and went to sleep with it, and when I woke up, it was still intact. So I can say it’s long wearing and didn’t smudge at all!” —ALP

Get it from Amazon for $7.99+ (available in four shades and also in a two pack).